Business Advice

Stripe vs Shopify Payments: which should you use

Content Team

Content Team

Summary

  • Shopify Payments and Stripe both charge 2.9% + USD $0.30 for most standard US online card transactions, but they're built for different use cases

  • If you use Shopify and Shopify Payments is available to you, using it avoids Shopify's third-party transaction fee which runs 0.2–2% depending on your plan making it the cheaper option for most Shopify merchants

  • Stripe is the stronger choice outside Shopify: better for SaaS, subscriptions, multi-platform businesses, or anything requiring custom payment flows

  • Shopify Payments is the stronger choice for Shopify merchants who want orders, payments, and payouts managed in one place

  • You can use both, but availability of Stripe as a third-party provider on Shopify depends on your country and plan check Shopify's current gateway list before assuming it's an option

One Aspire account to manage your business finances in one place.

Get a business account¹, issue corporate cards², manage expenses, and automate financial workflows, all from one powerful platform built for modern businesses.

Open an account for free

Shopify Payments and Stripe both start at the same headline card-processing rate in the US 2.9% + USD $0.30 per online transaction but they solve different problems. Shopify Payments is built into Shopify and avoids Shopify's third-party transaction fees. Stripe is a standalone payments platform built for websites, apps, subscriptions, marketplaces, and custom payment flows.

The decision point isn't the rate. It's where you sell, how you bill, and whether you need a payment layer that works across more than one platform. This guide covers the fee math, the feature differences, and how to make the right call based on your business model.

What's the actual difference between Stripe and Shopify Payments

Stripe is a standalone payment infrastructure platform. It processes payments across websites, apps, subscriptions, invoices, and marketplaces. It has no ecommerce platform attached; it's a payment layer you connect to whatever you're building.

Shopify Payments is Shopify's built-in payment processor. It's embedded directly into the Shopify admin, so orders, transactions, refunds, and payouts all live in one place. You activate it in settings and it works immediately no separate gateway setup required.

The comparison gets confusing because Shopify Payments was originally built on Stripe's infrastructure but they operate as separate products today with different pricing, different feature sets, and different optimal use cases. Shopify Payments is not Stripe with a Shopify logo on it.

Stripe vs Shopify Payments: quick comparison

FactorShopify PaymentsStripe
Platform typeBuilt into Shopify — not available elsewhereStandalone — works across any platform or custom build
Best forShopify merchants who want native, connected paymentsBusinesses selling across multiple platforms, SaaS, subscriptions, or custom apps
Online transaction fee (US)2.5%–2.9% + USD $0.30 depending on Shopify plan2.9% + USD $0.30 (flat, no platform subscription required)
Shopify platform surchargeVaries by shopify plan0.6%–2.0% added by Shopify when using as third-party gateway
Available countries39 countries (as of mid-2026)135+ currencies, 46+ countries
CustomizationLimited — uses Shopify's predefined checkoutHigh API-driven, fully customizable
SubscriptionsHas third-party and also free first party appsBuilt in via Stripe Billing
Payout timing3-5 business days (typically)2–7 business days
Ecommerce storeRequires Shopify subscription (USD $29–USD $2,300/month)No platform subscription required
Admin integrationOrders and payments in one dashboardSeparate dashboard from your store or product

Stripe vs Shopify fees: what you actually pay

The headline rates don't tell the full story. Here's what merchants actually pay in three scenarios.

If you use Shopify Payments on Shopify

Rates verified from Shopify's official pricing page:

Shopify planMonthly costOnline card rateExtra transaction fee
BasicUSD $29/month2.9% + USD $0.30None
GrowUSD $79/month2.7% + USD $0.30None
AdvancedUSD $299/month2.5% + USD $0.30None
PlusFrom ~USD $2,300/monthNegotiable (not published)None

What happens if you use a third-party payment provider on Shopify

Shopify can charge a third-party transaction fee in addition to the payment provider's own processing fee. The rate depends on the Shopify plan. Provider availability depends on the merchant's country and Shopify setup. Shopify adds a third-party gateway surcharge on top of third-party standard rate:

Shopify planStripe rateShopify surchargeEffective total
Basic2.9% + USD $0.30+2.0%4.9% + USD $0.30
Grow2.9% + USD $0.30+1.0%3.9% + USD $0.30
Advanced2.9% + USD $0.30+0.6%3.5% + USD $0.30
Plus2.9% + USD $0.30+0.2%~3.1% + USD $0.30

The surcharge makes sense to absorb only in specific situations: selling in countries where Shopify Payments isn't available, operating in a product category Shopify Payments doesn't support, or needing Stripe-specific capabilities (ACH at 0.8% capped at USD $5, B2B invoicing, or advanced billing logic) that justify the added cost.

If you use Stripe outside Shopify

Stripe charges 2.9% + USD $0.30 per online card transaction with no platform fee on top. In-person transactions are 2.7% + USD $0.05. International card transactions typically add around 1.5%.

How Stripe and Shopify Payments actually differ in practice

1. Checkout: one is built in, one is built for control

Shopify Payments runs checkout natively inside Shopify. That means orders, payment status, and customer data all live in one admin without any integration work.

Stripe gives you the opposite: control over every detail of how checkout behaves. You can embed payment forms in a mobile app, or build a completely custom checkout flow through.

If your revenue runs entirely through a Shopify storefront, Shopify Payments wins on simplicity. If your checkout needs to exist outside or alongside Shopify, Stripe is the more capable option.

2. Subscriptions: Stripe has a structural advantage for complex billing

Stripe Billing is purpose-built for recurring revenue. It handles billing cycles, failed payment retries, proration when customers upgrade mid-cycle, usage-based billing, and plan changes — all natively, without additional apps.

Shopify now offers its own Shopify Subscriptions app for basic recurring billing, which covers straightforward subscribe-and-save or fixed-cycle use cases without relying on a third party. Where Shopify's native capability falls short is complexity: usage-based billing, mid-cycle proration, and advanced plan logic still require third-party subscription apps, which adds cost and a dependency outside your core payment stack.

3. Integrations: Stripe is broader, Shopify Payments is deeper (inside Shopify)

Stripe is API-first and integrates with virtually everything accounting platforms, ERPs, CRMs, analytics tools, data warehouses.

Shopify Payments is narrower but tighter. If your entire operation runs inside Shopify orders, inventory, customer records, marketing analytics the native integration eliminates the reconciliation work that comes with connecting a third-party payment processor.

4. International reach: Stripe wins, but check whether it matters for you

Stripe processes payments in 135+ currencies . Shopify Payments covers approximately 39 countries. The gap matters directly if you're selling in markets where Shopify Payments isn't available in those cases, you either use Stripe (and pay the surcharge if you're still on Shopify) or set up a separate regional payment solution.

5. Payouts: small timing gap, bigger cash flow implications than it sounds

Shopify Payments typically settles in 3-5 business days. Stripe ranges from 2–7 days, though most established accounts land closer to 2–3. The difference looks minor, but for early-stage businesses managing tight cash flow around inventory restocking or supplier payment cycles, a 2-day gap in payout timing can create a real working capital squeeze.

6. Fraud and chargebacks: two different approaches to the same problem

Stripe Radar handles fraud detection automatically and is included in the standard rate. The upgraded version of Stripe Radar for Fraud Teams adds custom blocking rules and manual review queues for screened transactions.

Shopify Payments manages disputes inside the Shopify admin, alongside the order history, shipping confirmation, and customer communication for that transaction. When you need to respond to a chargeback, everything you'd typically pull together as evidence is already in one place.

Shopify Payments vs Stripe: Pros and Cons

Here is a list of different scenarios of where each might be the better choice than the other.

1. Shopify Payments

Where it wins:

  • No third-party surcharge on Shopify, it's consistently the cheaper option
  • Orders, payments, refunds, and payouts all live in one admin no reconciliation work between systems
  • Shop Pay unlocks accelerated checkout for returning customers, which isn't available with any other processor
  • Activates in minutes from your Shopify settings no separate integration or developer required
  • Processing rate drops as you move up Shopify plans, so costs improve with scale

Where it falls short:

  • Locked to Shopify the moment you sell outside it, Shopify Payments can't help
  • Subscription billing requires third-party apps, which adds cost and complexity
  • Geographic coverage is narrower roughly 39 countries versus Stripe's 135
  • Checkout is largely predefined customization is limited compared to building on Stripe's APIs
  • Migrating away from Shopify later means rebuilding your payment setup from scratch

2. Stripe

Where it wins:

  • Works across any website, app, platform, or custom build not tied to any one storefront
  • Stripe Billing is built for subscription revenue recurring charges, failed payment retries, proration, and usage-based billing all handled natively
  • API-first architecture gives developers full control over checkout behavior, payment logic, and data flow
  • Broader international reach 135+ currencies, 46+ countries
  • Integrates cleanly with accounting software, ERPs, analytics tools, and most finance stacks
  • Custom pricing available for high-volume merchants above USD $500,000/month

Where it falls short:

  • Using Stripe inside Shopify adds a 0.5–2% platform surcharge that makes it materially more expensive for most Shopify merchants
  • Non-standard implementations require engineering time it's not a plug-and-play setup
  • Reconciliation doesn't happen automatically finance teams need to build that process or use additional tools
  • Payout timing is slightly less predictable than Shopify Payments, especially in the early months of a new account

Which one is right for your business

This isn't a close call in most situations; the right answer follows from how and where you sell.

Use Shopify Payments if:

  • Shopify is your primary or only sales channel
  • You want payments, orders, and inventory managed in one place without additional tools
  • Setup speed matters you want to go live without a developer or separate integration
  • You're a DTC brand or physical products merchant focused on optimizing within the Shopify ecosystem
  • Avoiding the third-party surcharge is a priority, and Stripe's specific capabilities aren't relevant to your model

Use Stripe if:

  • You sell across multiple platforms, run a custom-built product, or operate outside Shopify
  • Subscriptions or usage-based billing are central to how you charge customers
  • You need checkout flows that Shopify's templates can't support — custom payment experiences, split payments, or in-app purchases
  • You're selling in markets where Shopify Payments isn't available and need broader geographic coverage
  • Your finance or engineering team needs API-level control over how payments integrate with the rest of your stack
  • You're building a marketplace or platform where payments need to flow between multiple sellers

One scenario that comes up often: founders who start on Shopify Payments and later launch a SaaS product or subscription offering. At that point, running Shopify Payments for the store and Stripe for the subscription layer is a reasonable split between each processor doing the job it's built for.

Can you use Stripe and Shopify Payments together?

Yes, in some cases. The most practical setup is using Shopify Payments for your Shopify storefront and Stripe separately for a different product or revenue stream: a SaaS subscription, a standalone app, or invoice-based billing where Stripe's capabilities are genuinely needed. Each processor handles its own channel, and you avoid paying Shopify's third-party surcharge on your store transactions.

Managing payments once you've chosen a processor

Once customer payments reach your business account, the financial workflow doesn't stop there. Supplier payments, team expenses, multi-currency transactions, and corporate card spend all need to be managed on the other side of that collection.

Aspire1 connects payment activity, expense management, multi-currency accounts*, and corporate cards2 into one platform, giving founders visibility across incoming revenue and outgoing costs without needing to stitch together multiple banking and payment tools.

For businesses operating across currencies or paying international vendors alongside their domestic payment processing, that consolidated view becomes more useful as volume increases.

Frequently Asked Questions

It depends on where you're selling. For businesses built on Shopify, Shopify Payments is almost always cheaper and simpler. For SaaS companies, multi-platform businesses, or anyone needing custom payment flows, Stripe is the stronger product. Neither is universally better.

On Shopify, yes in most cases. Using Shopify Payments avoids the 0.2–2% third-party gateway surcharge Shopify charges when you use Stripe instead. Outside Shopify, pricing depends on your plan, volume, and transaction type rather than a simple comparison.

Yes, but Shopify adds a 0.2–2% surcharge on every transaction when you use a third-party gateway. On a Basic plan, that's an extra 2% per sale — which makes Stripe materially more expensive than Shopify Payments for most Shopify merchants.

Stripe is a standalone payment processor that works across any website, app, or platform. Shopify Payments is a payment processor built into Shopify that only works within the Shopify ecosystem. They have similar base transaction rates but very different use cases, integration depth, and total costs when used inside Shopify.

Yes. Shopify adds a third-party gateway fee of 2% (Basic), 1% (Shopify plan), 0.6% (Advanced), or 0.2% (Plus) on every transaction processed through Stripe or any other non-Shopify Payments gateway.

For small businesses on Shopify, Shopify Payments removes the gateway surcharge and keeps operations simple. For small businesses selling through a custom website, using multiple sales channels, or running subscription products, Stripe's flat rate and flexibility typically make more sense. The right answer depends on your sales infrastructure, not your size.

Sources

This blog is for general information only and does not constitute financial, legal, tax, or professional advice. Aspire’s services are subject to the terms outlined in our ’Terms of Service’ and ’Pricing’ pages. We make no guarantees as to the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the content, and past results do not indicate future performance. Always consult a qualified professional before acting on any information provided.

Content Team

Content Team

Aspire editorial

Content team at Aspire is a society of seasoned writers & experts specialising in finance, technology and SaaS space. With 50+ years of collective experience, they help make business finance more profitable for readers. They write about finance tools, finance insights, industry trends, tactical guides to grow your business & also all things Aspire.

Aspire Launchpad

Supercharge your finance operations with Aspire

Find out how Aspire can help you speed up your end-to-end finance processes from payments to expense management.

Start your journey with Aspire