Virtual Debit Card vs Physical Debit Card: Which One is The Best for Your Business?

Published on
August 29, 2023
Written by
Ekky Pramana

The importance of physical and virtual debit cards in day-to-day business operations

Businesses nowadays need to be more flexible and adapt to changes, including how they handle transactions. There are two main options that have become the standard: virtual debit cards and physical debit cards. But for business in Indonesia, virtual debit cards are the lesser known of the two. Each of them has their pros and cons, so it's really important for Indonesian business owners to know the differences.

In this article, we'll look at these two options closely and compare them. We'll talk about what they're good at, where they might have problems, and what things you need to think about when you decide which one is right for your business. When you understand how they work, you can make smarter choices for your business, especially in the fast-changing world of transactions.

Debit cards are great because they help businesses pay really quickly and hassle-free. They also open the doors to doing business online and even in other countries, which can help a business grow and be more successful.

There are two kinds of debit cards: virtual and physical. Virtual ones are like digital versions of regular cards, and they're used mostly for buying things online. Physical ones are the actual cards you carry with you and use at stores and ATMs. Every business has different needs, so it's good to know what each type can do, how they can help streamline business transactions, and what challenges they might have.

Physical debit card: how does it work?

A physical debit card is the conventional form of a payment card that you can hold and use for various real-world financial transactions. This card is directly linked to your bank account and often features widely accepted payment networks, such as Visa or Mastercard. Its functions include a range of activities, such as payments at physical stores, restaurants, and other offline businesses. Additionally, a physical debit card enables you to withdraw cash at ATMs, making it a highly practical tool for everyday transaction needs.

Physical debit cards are commonly used as legitimate financial identification tools, allowing businesses to present a professional image in the eyes of customers. Despite being traditional, physical debit cards remain a crucial element in the modern business payment infrastructure, facilitating physical transactions quickly, easily, and securely.

The pros of Physical Debit Cards for Businesses

Physical debit cards also offer specific benefits to businesses, particularly in providing convenience for employee spending. In a business setting, physical debit cards can be issued to employees as a means to access company funds swiftly and efficiently. This eliminates the need to submit cash expenses or wait for reimbursement processes, which can disrupt productivity.

Employees can use physical debit cards for everyday business-related purchases, such as office supplies and consumables, without having to use their personal funds upfront. Furthermore, providing physical debit cards enables companies to easily track and manage employee expenses with transparent transaction records. With this feature in place, physical debit cards offer a practical solution that streamlines internal business spending processes and enhances operational efficiency.

The cons of Physical Debit Cards for Businesses

However, it cannot be overlooked that physical debit cards also have some drawbacks that businesses should consider before fully adopting them. One of these weaknesses is the risk of physical card loss or theft. If a physical debit card falls into the wrong hands, sensitive information could be exposed and used for unauthorized transactions. Additionally, some online transactions may require alternative forms of payment that cannot be accommodated by physical debit cards, potentially hindering a business's flexibility in online transactions.

Furthermore, businesses also need to take into account the production and distribution costs of physical cards, especially in cases where the business operates at a large scale involving numerous employees or customers. In some instances, these costs of issuing multiple physical cards can be a significant addition to the business budget. Businesses need to carefully consider whether the advantages outweigh the disadvantages and if they align with their needs and financial objectives.

Virtual debit card: how does it work?

Virtual debit cards are a significant innovation in the world of financial transactions, providing a modern solution to meet the needs of businesses and consumers for securing and simplifying online payments. Unlike their physical counterparts, virtual debit cards are digital representations directly linked to your bank account. They work similarly to physical debit cards but offer additional advantages in terms of security and flexibility. Virtual debit cards enable you to generate a unique card number, expiration date, and security code (CVV) for each transaction, reducing the risk of fraud and data breaches. In other words, virtual debit cards create an extra layer of protection while facilitating quick and efficient electronic transactions.

The pros of virtual debit card for businesses

Virtual debit cards offer several valuable advantages for businesses in managing their financial operations. One key aspect is enhanced security when conducting online transactions. With virtual debit cards, you can generate unique card details for each transaction, reducing the risk of fraud and data theft, safeguarding businesses from financial losses and reputation damage resulting from security breaches.

Another advantage is the ease of conducting international transactions. Virtual debit cards, especially those linked to Visa and Mastercard networks, can be used worldwide without geographic limitations, enabling businesses to expand their reach and operate globally without significant barriers.

Virtual debit cards also enable businesses to better manage finances through customizable spending limits. This feature helps control budgets and prevent overspending, reducing the risk of transaction fraud by employees, thus aiding businesses in maintaining a healthy and sustainable financial path. With all these benefits, virtual debit cards prove themselves as effective and efficient tools in assisting businesses to achieve their financial goals.

The cons of virtual debit card for businesses

However, like any solution, virtual debit cards also have some drawbacks that businesses need to consider before fully adopting them. One limitation is their restricted usability in physical locations. Virtual debit cards are primarily intended for online transactions, making them less suitable for in-store purchases or situations where cash payments are required. Additionally, while virtual debit cards are digitally secure, the possibility of technical issues or access blocks still exist, which could disrupt business operations and cause inconvenience.

Another drawback: for businesses frequently dealing with cash transactions, virtual debit cards might not be the most practical choice since they do not provide the option to withdraw cash from ATMs. In this case, businesses need to weigh whether the advantages of virtual debit cards can outweigh these limitations and whether they align with their business model.

Important considerations when choosing the right debit card for your business

When deciding on the most suitable type of debit card for your business, it's crucial to consider several factors that will impact financial efficiency, transaction flexibility, and risk protection. The choice between physical and virtual debit cards isn't a trivial one; it's a strategic consideration that can influence various aspects of your business operations.

In this segment, we'll delve deeper into the factors to be taken into account, aiding you in making informed and wise decisions when selecting the appropriate payment path to drive your business growth and success.

Types of daily transactions

Business should consider choosing between physical card and virtual card based on the dominant daily transactions in your business operations. If your business heavily involves online or digital transactions, like selling products or services through digital platforms, then a virtual debit card can provide the convenience and security needed to manage those transactions. Unique card numbers for each transaction offer extra protection against security risks and online fraud.

However, if your business relies more on physical transactions at customer locations or stores, then a physical debit card might be more relevant. It offers flexibility for in-person payments and the ease of withdrawing cash from ATMs if necessary. By considering the most frequent types of daily transactions, you can choose the debit card type that best supports your business operational needs.

Security

One vital consideration when choosing a debit card type is the level of transaction security. Virtual debit cards provide an extra layer of protection for online transactions. With its ability to generate unique card numbers for each transaction, virtual debit cards reduce the risk of fraud and data breaches that are prevalent in online transactions. On the other hand, physical debit cards can also have significant security features, such as EMV chip technology that reduces the risk of data breaches and card misuse.

Choosing the right debit card type should factor in how much you want to protect your business transactions from security risks, whether in online transactions or in-person transactions at customer locations. By selecting a debit card type that aligns with your business's security needs, you can better safeguard your cash flow.

International transactions needs

In the increasingly global business world, it’s important to make considerations based on whether your business operates globally or within the border. Virtual debit cards can offer an advantage here due to their flexibility in cross-border transactions. With a virtual debit card, businesses can easily make payments in foreign currencies and overcome international payment barriers. The unique card numbers for each transaction also help reduce security risks in international transactions. However, it's important to ensure that the card issuer supports international transactions and has proficiency in dealing with foreign currencies.

On the other hand, physical debit cards can also be used for international transactions but might require additional issuer approval or have certain limitations. By considering your business's needs for cross-border transactions, you can choose a debit card type that offers convenience and reliability in international transactions, aligning with your vision for business expansion and global growth.

Ease of financial management

A virtual debit card can offer convenience in this aspect with its feature of adjustable transaction limits for each issued card. This allows you to control your business budget better and prevent overspending. Virtual debit cards also facilitate organized transaction recording, making it easy for your business to do financial tracking and analysis.

However, if your business does require cash payments or daily physical transactions, a physical debit card can provide ease in making in-person purchases or quickly withdrawing cash from ATMs.

Cost

Cost is a key factor that needs careful consideration when selecting the debit card type that fits your business. Virtual and physical debit cards might have different fee structures that require thorough evaluation. Virtual debit cards may have administration fees or specific transaction charges associated with their usage, particularly in online transactions or international transfers. Nevertheless, the added security features and convenience in managing online transactions might help offset these costs. On the other hand, physical debit cards may involve card issuance and distribution fees, along with potential additional charges for ATM usage or specific transactions.

Consider these costs in the context of your business needs and compare them against the benefits offered by each card type. By thoroughly understanding the fee structure and potential savings, you can make informed decisions in choosing a debit card type that aligns with your business budget and financial goals.

Infrastructure availability

Infrastructure availability also plays a significant role in choosing the most suitable debit card type for your business. Virtual debit cards require stable internet access and reliable online banking systems to smoothly conduct transactions. Ensure that your business has adequate access to this infrastructure before opting for virtual debit card usage. On the other hand, physical debit cards can be more flexible in terms of availability, as they can be used in various locations without depending on a stable internet connection.

Also, consider the payment infrastructure for businesses around you, which is especially important in countries like Indonesia, particularly for transactions outside major urban areas that may not fully support cashless transactions. In such circumstances, physical debit cards become a better choice, especially if you need to withdraw cash from ATMs for transactions.

When making a decision, ensure that the required infrastructure for the chosen debit card type is available or accessible within your business's operational scope, allowing financial transactions to proceed smoothly without unnecessary hindrances.

Aspire corporate card, the best option for virtual debit card for business in Indonesia

Aspire, a leading fintech company in Southeast Asia, provides a range of benefits to help manage your company's finances, one of which is the virtual debit card for business payments. Aspire offers all the advantages of a modern virtual debit card, such as the card limit feature that allows companies to issue multiple cards with different transaction limits for different needs, reducing the risk of overspending.

The real-time monitoring feature on the Aspire app enables businesses to track all transactions made on the debit cards used by employees, reducing the risks of fraud. This feature allows management to maintain tight control over all employee spending activities, which will positively impact the company's cash flow.

In addition to offering modern features, the Aspire debit card also provides a variety of attractive benefits, including unlimited cashback for transactions at various top global merchants such as Google Workspace, AWS, Adobe, Figma, Slack, and many more.

The array of features and benefits offered by the Aspire virtual debit card makes it one of the best solutions for businesses in need of an advanced payment tool to streamline their daily transaction activities.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Ekky Pramana is a seasoned writer specialising in business finance and management. With a writing history at Tech in Asia, Teknoverso, and various other publishers, he leverages his market expertise to empower and educate first-time founders in managing their businesses better.
Ekky Pramana
Read less
Aspire is the all-in-one finance operating system for businesses. Our mission is to empower the next generation of entrepreneurs with the financial tools they need to realise their company’s full potential.
Learn more about us.
Ready to get started?
Aspire makes business finance easier - expense management, invoicing, FX, employee claims and more. This is the all-in-one finance OS for your business
Try it out today >>
Subscribe
Get high quality finance and entrepreneurial resources in your inbox.
Subscribe to the newsletter >>

Get high quality finance and business content in your inbox

Get insights and resources on building & managing your finance team, your finance tech stack and growing your business
Cheers! We'll share our best articles with you shortly. See you around!
Seems like something went wrong. Could you try again?

Explore the all-in-one finance solution built for finance teams

Save time and money with borderless payments, corporate cards, expense management, and more